It’s a common scenario described to us at Sierra HR: An employee who has been struggling to keep up with performance expectations submits a doctor’s note stating they need a leave of absence or remote work due to stress and anxiety. “Do we really have to approve that?” the exasperated manager asks. The answer (in our best Doug Larsen imitation): “It depends.”
Employers are increasingly navigating employee issues involving mental health and stress-related limitations. While requests for modified schedules, remote work, or other adjustments can be difficult to manage, there is an important proactive step to be taken long before an accommodation is requested: make sure job descriptions accurately reflect the cognitive demands of each position.
Job descriptions usually focus on essential duties, qualifications, and physical requirements such as lifting or operating equipment. But most jobs also involve significant cognitive demands. Employees may need to maintain calm and focus in busy environments, communicate effectively with upset customers, and manage multiple deadlines and priorities. These requirements can be just as important to successful performance as physical abilities, yet they are often overlooked in a written job description.
Start With the Actual Requirements of the Job: Consider an administrative position in a busy office. The work may require frequent interruptions, urgent requests from clients, and the ability to adjust priorities throughout the day. Rather than simply stating that the employee must “work well under pressure” or “handle stress,” a more useful job description could include: Must be able to manage multiple customer requests, shift between tasks as priorities change, and maintain accurate and professional communication during periods of high activity.
Clearly defined cognitive requirements can also support the recruiting and interviewing process. Employers can develop behavior-based questions that explore how candidates have handled comparable situations in previous jobs. For example: “Tell me about a time when you were managing several competing priorities and an unexpected customer need required your immediate attention. How did you decide what to address first?”
This allows employers to evaluate job-related skills and experience without asking inappropriate questions about a candidate’s mental health or disability history.
A Better Foundation for Accommodation Discussions: Accurate job descriptions become especially valuable when an employee requests an accommodation related to a mental health condition. An employee experiencing anxiety may request to work remotely because the office environment makes it difficult to concentrate. Rather than immediately approving or denying the request based on company policy, the employer can use the job description to explore possible solutions based on the needs of the job. Would a quieter workspace help? Could interruptions be reduced? Would adjusted work hours or a hybrid schedule allow the employee to perform the essential functions of the position while maintaining office operations?
Balancing Employee Needs and Business Operations: California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) requires employers to engage in a good-faith interactive process to consider an employee’s request for accommodation, but they are not required to eliminate essential job functions or provide accommodations that create an undue hardship. Well-written job descriptions provide a consistent starting point for these discussions, helping to clarify essential functions and necessary cognitive abilities so managers can feel more confident in weighing possible options.
Mental health concerns will continue to be part of our employment landscape, so managers are encouraged to use job descriptions as a valuable resource. Including clearly defined job-related cognitive demands can improve hiring decisions, explain performance expectations, and provide a valuable foundation for future accommodation discussions.
Written by Janet Keene, SPHR, Senior HR Consultant, Sierra HR Partners.






